Our November Competition
User Reviews - Add Yours!
The PCHF Lounge
Go Back   PC Help Forum » Operating Systems » Windows Vista & 7
Register for a Free Account

Windows Vista & 7 - Installing Windows 7 ON a USB drive posted in the Operating Systems forums; Originally Posted by Cobracon LOL! That's a good one, GS. I feel safe in guaranteeing the driver incompatability issue has been wrestled with by better minds, and there STILL isn't ...


Closed Thread
Scan your PC for Errors
Old 3 Weeks Ago   #22
Tech Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 66
PC Experience: Experienced, but always learning!
Default Re: Installing Windows 7 ON a USB drive

Originally Posted by Cobracon View Post

LOL! That's a good one, GS. I feel safe in guaranteeing the driver incompatability issue has been wrestled with by better minds, and there STILL isn't an answer. Fact is, driver incompatability between brands and form factors is a good thing for manufacturers. Good thing = money/sales/exclusivity. Why would company 'A' want their drivers to work on company 'B' equipment? They don't. How many questions on this site alone deal with driver searches? LOTS! Believe me, if a bypass was available someone would have created it and made a boatload of cash off the solution by now.

As for the legality issue and interpretation of the whole drive/computer discussion, why not just email Microsoft and bounce your idea off them? I have no doubt this brainstorm has crossed their collective desk more than once already. My educated guess is that their response will be, "Why of course you can't do that you little whippersnapper!", or 4 letter words to that effect. It's not in Microsoft's best interest to allow anything which resembles running one O/S on multiple computers, even if the particular bypass appears to be used on only one computer at a time. Unless of course a person is willing to come off some cash. Microsoft has that aspect covered, too.
Alright, I'll e-mail them and get the word.

I just realized some thing. Almost every one in this discussion is saying Microsoft frowns upon using an OS on two computers at the same time. Well, what about when I am using Logmein, which is a COMPLETELY legal remote control program? The OS is being used on two computers, one running on the main computer, and a completely different computer using the OS on that computer. You see? This is a legal program, but technically it should be breaking a law. If you are talking about INSTALLING the OS on two computers, then the legal issues involved with that are entirely different. You cannot install two operating systems which have the same key, and if you do it is because you some how hacked the OS or validation registry files. I don't know how to it, and never will. I would simply uninstall the Windows 7 RC on my partition, and non simply re install it on my USB drive, and there is one install of one OS.

Originally Posted by lucianp View Post

Oh dear, I really opened a can of worms when I spoke out of turn, didn't I?

Let me clarify some things and try to set my own record straight.
NO it does not. The information I gave you does not prove a single thing. I said it was my interpretation which does not necessarily mean it would stand up in court. Please do not take what I say as gospel. (in this instance anyway).
Ok, I understand, but I still appreciate you being more optimistic about the subject. What you said was a good way to think of it; like some one who actually isn't a lawyer on this forum.

I still need to read those EULA files; I could not print them and read at school because we ran out of ink.

Never mind about contacting Microsoft. It costs 50 dollars, and google doesn't tell me ANY THING!

Guys, just let me say this; OMFG.

Last edited by GravitySphere; 3 Weeks Ago at 01:40 AM.
GravitySphere is offline  
Advertisement - Register to Remove
Old 3 Weeks Ago   #23
Tech Support Team
 
samuria's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 625
PC Experience: PC Guru
Default Re: Installing Windows 7 ON a USB drive

To do it you really need to use Bart Pe this gives you a live system which will work with any hardware. It doesnt support win7 yet but you can do Vista.xp etc.

Without it your drive may not boot as the hardware may be different with every pc
__________________
Prework

Record holder of the one inch punch
http://www.winchun-tao.co.uk/
samuria is offline  
Old 3 Weeks Ago   #24
Tech Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 66
PC Experience: Experienced, but always learning!
Default Re: Installing Windows 7 ON a USB drive

Originally Posted by samuria View Post
To do it you really need to use Bart Pe this gives you a live system which will work with any hardware. It doesnt support win7 yet but you can do Vista.xp etc.

Without it your drive may not boot as the hardware may be different with every pc
Can you tell me exactly how to use this and what to do with it? I am using Vista.
GravitySphere is offline  
Old 3 Weeks Ago   #25
Deceptively Clever CC&BW
 
Cobracon's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: North of Hurricane Bay & South of Tornado Alley "Stuck-in-the-Middle", MS.
Posts: 1,338
PC Experience: D'OH!! *&^%$#@!
Default Re: Installing Windows 7 ON a USB drive

Originally Posted by GravitySphere View Post
Alright, I'll e-mail them and get the word.

I just realized some thing. Almost every one in this discussion is saying Microsoft frowns upon using an OS on two computers at the same time. Well, what about when I am using Logmein, which is a COMPLETELY legal remote control program? The OS is being used on two computers, one running on the main computer, and a completely different computer using the OS on that computer. You see?
You misunderstand the way LogMeIn works (or I do - LOL). The O/S on the 'controller' PC is manipulating the O/S on the 'controlled' PC. Two different O/S's, two different computers. Think about it. You couldn't log onto a distant computer if it didn't have it's own O/S and was up and running. LogMeIn doesn't magically transfer one O/S onto the other computer and bring it to life. That's why it's COMPLETELY legal.

We could continue beating this dead horse from now 'til doomsday and in the end, Microsoft's interpretation is the only one that matters. That's why I suggested getting a ruling from them. I'll bet good money they shoot the idea down. Like I said, this idea has surely crossed their collective desk numerous times. There is no doubt in my mind this potential loophole has been long closed.
__________________


"Have you scanned the RAM timings for Operator's Headspace?? Too much real estate between the audio collectors will block the connection which allows proper operation of your computer." __Cobra
PCHF best helps those who best help themselves.
PC Guru you say.........? Are you suuuuure about that?
Cobracon is online now  
Old 3 Weeks Ago   #26
Tech Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 66
PC Experience: Experienced, but always learning!
Default Re: Installing Windows 7 ON a USB drive

Guys, I think I found the answer. I will use How To Make and Use a Bootable WinPE Drive : USB Flash Drives to do my project. I am downloading the WAIK (from Microsoft.com, which as you know my validates that the copy of Windows installed is genuine, which it did for me, and so I downloaded the file legally), and will use the guide to run Vista with WinPE off of my USB stick. I do not have a Windows Vista Install disk because my computer didn't come with one, so I cannot do the WinRE thing, but I don't need that. WinPE is exactly, or maybe even better, than what I wanted originally; the ability to boot Windows from a USB stick, and specifically on any computer, because WinPE is designed to work on ANY computer. Really guys, did no one think of this? Plus, it is even more legal than what I was originally trying to do (I think, right??), if that were illegal in any way. Before I go on, are there any objections?

Last edited by GravitySphere; 3 Weeks Ago at 04:01 AM.
GravitySphere is offline  
Old 3 Weeks Ago   #27
Tech Team Leader
 
DCiAdmin's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Heart of the US Midwest
Posts: 6,179
PC Experience: Perpetual Student
Default Re: Installing Windows 7 ON a USB drive

LOL, GS

Not a thought of WinPE. Good find EDIT: Network access sounds possible - but note, that doesn't mean the same as *Internet* access.....

btw, according to Wikipedia: Windows PE 3.0 - Built from Windows 7 code base. It is included in WAIK 2.0.

Have fun! Please let us know if there is anything further you require AND how this goes for you. And please contribute often. Out of the box thinking - as long as it's legal - is always appreciated! LOL
__________________
DCiAdmin
PCHF Rules / PreWork / AfterWork / PCHF Downloads / System File Checker
Thank you for entrusting your system to PCHF!

Last edited by DCiAdmin; 3 Weeks Ago at 05:13 AM. Reason: re-read...
DCiAdmin is offline  
Old 3 Weeks Ago   #28
Tech Support Team
 
Wolfeymole's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: In the Slaughtered Lamb having a pint.
Posts: 4,489
PC Experience: Smarter than the average Bear
Default Re: Installing Windows 7 ON a USB drive

WinPE is exactly, or maybe even better, than what I wanted originally; the ability to boot Windows from a USB stick, and specifically on any computer, because WinPE is designed to work on ANY computer.
I think you need to re-read your own link again GS because it seems to me that you are under the assumption that the advice offered in that link allows you to fully "install" windows from a USB anywhere.

All it does is allow a quicker method to repair rather than using the RC.
Comments on this post
Cobracon agrees: TRGB.......
__________________

If PCHF has helped you please consider a donation by clicking this link Donate




Wolfeymole is online now  

Closed Thread


Bookmarks

Tags
drive, installing, usb, windows
Similar discussions...
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Answered: Installing windows xp on a new drive ghostlyshark Windows XP/2000 4 04-29-2009 02:33 PM
[Answered] destination drive name confusion after installing new drive Brendan Windows XP/2000 1 04-16-2007 09:07 AM
Installing Windows after formatting a hard drive bhsparks Windows XP/2000 2 07-28-2006 01:28 AM
Installing new hard drive/Windows xp recovery software? chris_83 Unfinished Threads 5 05-24-2006 09:50 AM
[Fixed] - Having trouble installing windows from a pcmcia cd drive, pls help. Bruce85 Windows 95, 98 & ME 20 11-16-2005 03:30 AM

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are On




All times are GMT. The time now is 09:03 AM.
Powered by vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.3.2