Our November Competition
User Reviews - Add Yours!
The PCHF Lounge
Go Back   PC Help Forum » Operating Systems » Windows Vista & 7
Register for a Free Account

Windows Vista & 7 - Installing Windows 7 ON a USB drive posted in the Operating Systems forums; I am terribly sorry, GravitySphere, but you misunderstand. Microsoft sells their Operating Systems to be legally installed on 1 computer. A USB stick is not a computer, therefore not acceptable ...


Closed Thread
Recommended Driver Scanner
Old 3 Weeks Ago   #15
Tech Team Leader
 
DCiAdmin's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Heart of the US Midwest
Posts: 6,179
PC Experience: Perpetual Student
Default Re: Installing Windows 7 ON a USB drive

I am terribly sorry, GravitySphere, but you misunderstand.

Microsoft sells their Operating Systems to be legally installed on 1 computer. A USB stick is not a computer, therefore not acceptable for an installation.

Please refer back to the Microsoft EULA referenced by Wolfeymole.
Comments on this post
Cobracon agrees: Excellent point.
__________________
DCiAdmin
PCHF Rules / PreWork / AfterWork / PCHF Downloads / System File Checker
Thank you for entrusting your system to PCHF!
DCiAdmin is offline  
Advertisement - Register to Remove
Old 3 Weeks Ago   #16
Deceptively Clever CC&BW
 
Cobracon's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: North of Hurricane Bay & South of Tornado Alley "Stuck-in-the-Middle", MS.
Posts: 1,337
PC Experience: D'OH!! *&^%$#@!
Default Re: Installing Windows 7 ON a USB drive

Legalities aside, you're still going to run into driver issues when switching between computers with different brands of hardware and/or form factors.
Comments on this post
DCiAdmin agrees: as is yours :)
__________________


"Have you scanned the RAM timings for Operator's Headspace?? Too much real estate between the audio collectors will block the connection which allows proper operation of your computer." __Cobra
PCHF best helps those who best help themselves.
PC Guru you say.........? Are you suuuuure about that?
Cobracon is offline  
Old 3 Weeks Ago   #17
Tech Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 66
PC Experience: Experienced, but always learning!
Default Re: Installing Windows 7 ON a USB drive

Originally Posted by Cobracon View Post
Legalities aside, you're still going to run into driver issues when switching between computers with different brands of hardware and/or form factors.
True, but maybe there would be a way to by pass that. I know you guys have some good skills, and maybe I could get help on fixing that issue, and make it possible. I know I sound might sound a bit too excited, but I am dead serious.

Originally Posted by DCiAdmin View Post
I am terribly sorry, GravitySphere, but you misunderstand.

Microsoft sells their Operating Systems to be legally installed on 1 computer. A USB stick is not a computer, therefore not acceptable for an installation.

Please refer back to the Microsoft EULA referenced by Wolfeymole.
I believe a hard drive placed inside a computer is not a computer either, so that means every computer in the world is illegally running a copy of Windows. Also, if you are quoting the EULA properly, you are saying "installed" on one computer. To talk non sarcastically with you, this process would indeed involve the installation of one operating system on one computer, so I really don't so a major difference. A USB flash drive is a hard drive, just to remind you. All we install OS's on are internal hard drives. But like you said to, I will make sure to read all of the End-User license agreement because I don't want to go to far with this without having my facts straight; so I'll print and read it at school. Talk to you guys later.

And thank you, this is a really good discussion, and it alone is helping me to make the right decision. I guess it has to start with the legal issues so no one gets in trouble (you guys!).

Last edited by GravitySphere; 3 Weeks Ago at 03:07 PM.
GravitySphere is offline  
Old 3 Weeks Ago   #18
Tech Support Team
 
Wolfeymole's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: In the Slaughtered Lamb having a pint.
Posts: 4,485
PC Experience: Smarter than the average Bear
Default Re: Installing Windows 7 ON a USB drive

Here's the simple facts ok Gravity which you seem to have trouble grasping.

A hard drive is an integral part of a pc, a usb stick is not.

You need a computer with a hard drive that contains windows so you can transfer any material from a cd or dvd disk on to a usb stick.

As Cobra said you will have system hardware parameter errors in attempting to transfer an operating system between multiple computers when it was originally installed on just one.
__________________

If PCHF has helped you please consider a donation by clicking this link Donate





Last edited by Wolfeymole; 3 Weeks Ago at 03:09 PM.
Wolfeymole is online now  
Old 3 Weeks Ago   #19
PCHF VIP
 
lucianp's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Tornado Alley, 4200m East of the Bunker
Posts: 275
PC Experience: There's always more to learn.
Default Re: Installing Windows 7 ON a USB drive

Oh dear, I really opened a can of worms when I spoke out of turn, didn't I?

I should have defragged my brain before I installed Thoughts. If only I could do a restore to yesterday...

Let me clarify some things and try to set my own record straight.
This information you gave proves that if I were to attempt to install the software on a USB flash drive and then use the drive on another computer, it would be legal."
NO it does not. The information I gave you does not prove a single thing. I said it was my interpretation which does not necessarily mean it would stand up in court. Please do not take what I say as gospel. (in this instance anyway).


Because the legalities can be interpreted in so many ways it would be unwise of this forum to suggest that you can legally do it. What I said on this forum was my opinion, and my opinion only. Not the forums. What the good folks on this forum are saying is that it may/may not be legal and until that is clarified - legally - this forum could not endorse your actions.

When I said " go for it", what I really meant was that people should think outside the box, they should challenge the status quo but they should also look at the legal, social, financial, political and whatever other ramifications their actions may have.

This is an excellent forum for helping each other with computer problems, questions and ideas but it also has guidelines which must be maintained. I may have overstepped that.
lucianp is offline  
Old 3 Weeks Ago   #20
Deceptively Clever CC&BW
 
Cobracon's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: North of Hurricane Bay & South of Tornado Alley "Stuck-in-the-Middle", MS.
Posts: 1,337
PC Experience: D'OH!! *&^%$#@!
Default Re: Installing Windows 7 ON a USB drive

Originally Posted by GravitySphere View Post
True, but maybe there would be a way to by pass that. I know you guys have some good skills, and maybe I could get help on fixing that issue, and make it possible. I know I sound might sound a bit too excited, but I am dead serious.
LOL! That's a good one, GS. I feel safe in guaranteeing the driver incompatability issue has been wrestled with by better minds, and there STILL isn't an answer. Fact is, driver incompatability between brands and form factors is a good thing for manufacturers. Good thing = money/sales/exclusivity. Why would company 'A' want their drivers to work on company 'B' equipment? They don't. How many questions on this site alone deal with driver searches? LOTS! Believe me, if a bypass was available someone would have created it and made a boatload of cash off the solution by now.

As for the legality issue and interpretation of the whole drive/computer discussion, why not just email Microsoft and bounce your idea off them? I have no doubt this brainstorm has crossed their collective desk more than once already. My educated guess is that their response will be, "Why of course you can't do that you little whippersnapper!", or 4 letter words to that effect. It's not in Microsoft's best interest to allow anything which resembles running one O/S on multiple computers, even if the particular bypass appears to be used on only one computer at a time. Unless of course a person is willing to come off some cash. Microsoft has that aspect covered, too.
__________________


"Have you scanned the RAM timings for Operator's Headspace?? Too much real estate between the audio collectors will block the connection which allows proper operation of your computer." __Cobra
PCHF best helps those who best help themselves.
PC Guru you say.........? Are you suuuuure about that?
Cobracon is offline  
Old 3 Weeks Ago   #21
PCHF Founder & Owner
 
Hengis's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: The PCHF Bunker
Posts: 14,085
PC Experience: Microsoft Certified Professional
Default Re: Installing Windows 7 ON a USB drive

Originally Posted by Cobracon View Post
As for the legality issue and interpretation of the whole drive/computer discussion, why not just email Microsoft and bounce your idea off them?
As we run a friendly "ship" here and this type of debate always has the opportunity to go skywards, Cobra's idea is the best so far.
__________________
Hengis is offline  

Closed Thread


Bookmarks

Tags
drive, installing, usb, windows
Similar discussions...
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Answered: Installing windows xp on a new drive ghostlyshark Windows XP/2000 4 04-29-2009 02:33 PM
[Answered] destination drive name confusion after installing new drive Brendan Windows XP/2000 1 04-16-2007 09:07 AM
Installing Windows after formatting a hard drive bhsparks Windows XP/2000 2 07-28-2006 01:28 AM
Installing new hard drive/Windows xp recovery software? chris_83 Unfinished Threads 5 05-24-2006 09:50 AM
[Fixed] - Having trouble installing windows from a pcmcia cd drive, pls help. Bruce85 Windows 95, 98 & ME 20 11-16-2005 03:30 AM

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are On




All times are GMT. The time now is 08:24 AM.
Powered by vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.3.2